Letter to the Editor 6-12-14
Lots of people are buzzing about headlines that appeared in newspapers across the state this past week. Finally, the worsening fiscal condition of the state seems to be getting widespread attention.
Former state budget director Duane Goossen, in a talk with the League of Women Voters, forecasted that the State will be in the red in one year. The following day Revenue Secretary Nick Jordan attacked Goossen’s credibility and denounced his revenue projections as untrue.
Duane Goossen is one of the most credible people who has served our state. He worked as budget director under three governors – Democrat and Republican – and served 14 years in the Kansas House of Representatives as a Republican, mostly on the budget-writing committee. He served as one of the six revenue forecasters for 12 years. Duane’s numbers and projections are consistently accurate and reliable.
Remember, state tax revenues fell $217 million short of projections in May. The drop in revenues for both April and May puts tax revenues $310 million below estimates for the fiscal year with only one month left. That is an undisputed fact.
But Jordan said it wasn’t the fault of Governor Sam Brownback’s tax plan but was due to changes in federal tax policy that caused many taxpayers to take capital gains the prior year. Jordan also quoted a Rockefeller Foundation study to support his position.
This claim did not hold up under scrutiny.
Several newspapers reported that an analyst with the Rockefeller Foundation said that Kansas leaders misrepresented her research on the cause of the state tax revenue drop and that Kansas could be forced to make cuts in the near future. “In Kansas it’s really not of that much importance,” the analyst said, referring to the capital gains tax changes in a phone call to a reporter at the Wichita Eagle.
So, why are Brownback revenue officials misleading the public? It boils down to the November election.
Brownback made his income tax reduction plan the centerpiece of his administration’s accomplishments – putting Kansas on a “glide path to zero” in order to grow the state. However, study after study shows that cutting taxes, especially the way it was done in Kansas, doesn’t produce economic growth. And the severity of the cuts is eating away at the things Kansans hold dear – good public schools, quality roads, and services for vulnerable populations. Without these, our quality of life suffers and growth will elude Kansas.
Goossen is right about the revenue forecasts leaving the Kansas budget in the red in a year.
The Rockefeller Foundation analyst is right about the cause of the downturn in revenues being attributable mostly to Brownback’s tax plan, not changes in federal tax policy.
Last year the revenue department estimated that the drop-off in revenues attributable to the treatment of capital gains was approximately $30 million, not $217 million. Even if no one reported capital gains for 2013, the fiscal note would only be about $100 million – not $217 million, the actual size of the shortfall.
In the eight years I served as Secretary of Revenue, (2003-2010) I always gave straight-forward, honest answers. It is sad for me to see revenue officials misleading Kansans about the fiscal condition of the state in order to sway public opinion prior to the election.
There are no actual winners . . . It was a long time ago. I was a transfer student, fresh from the hills, going into an auditorium because I wanted to hear a debate between two students, one a Jew and the other, as I recall, a Palestinian. Each obviously was passionate... [More]
Dear Editor, On January 22nd, sixty-five adventurous people arrived at the Brown Grand Theatre to hear the first concert in a new classical music series offered by theater director Emily Krampe and her board. This was no high-brow event, but rather, a refreshing,... [More]
District Court CIVIL Dismissed: The case of the State of Kansas, Cloud County Attorney Robert Walsh vs. 2003 Mitsubishi, VIN 4A3AC44G23E203843 Petition to Kansas Standard Asset Seizure and Forfeiture Act has been dismissed without prejudice. Plaintiff is exempt from costs. Filed:... [More]
Police Dept. Report Theft—Ron Regnier, Concordia, reported at 9 a.m., Jan. 29, a Theft which had occurred in the 500 block of East 9th. Under investigation. Betty Powell, Concordia, reported at 1 p.m., Jan. 29, a Theft which had occurred in the 600 block of 2nd Avenue.... [More]
The renovation of Arley Bryant Gymnasium is moving forward after the Cloud County Community College board of trustees approved a $218,000 bid Tuesday night to replace the bleachers. The replacement of the bleachers is part of a $450,000 gym renovation project. In... [More]
Concordia High School senior Jera Metro has signed a letter of intent to play volleyball at Kansas Wesleyan University. A 5-6 hitter, Metro had 208 kills to rank second on the Concordia team. Metro had 253 digs and a 90.4 serving percentage. Concordia finished... [More]
The ball was where the Cloud County Thunderbirds wanted it — in the hands of point guard Devon Thomas — and as he had all night, Thomas delivered. With the T-Birds trailing 25th-ranked Barton Community College 94-93, Thomas took an inbounds pass with 4.6... [More]